Skip to main content
Alternatives

Wood Fibre vs Mineral Wool Insulation

How they compare on cost, thermal and acoustic performance, fire, moisture, and sustainability

9 min readUpdated November 2026

Save guide

Photo: Øyvind Holmstad · CC0

The short answer

Both are good insulation materials, and neither is the right answer everywhere. Mineral wool is usually cheaper, is non-combustible, and is the default where fire rules are strict. Wood fibre is denser, buffers moisture, and stores biogenic carbon, which suits vapour-open build-ups, roofs at risk of summer heat, and many retrofits.

"Mineral wool" covers two different materials. Glass wool is spun from molten glass, often with a high share of recycled glass, and is typically light, as in loft rolls. Stone wool (also called rock wool) is spun from molten rock and is usually denser. They differ in weight, cost, and carbon, so compare the actual product, not the family name.

Wood fibre also comes in different forms: light flexible batts for stud and rafter cavities, and denser rigid boards for sarking, sheathing, and render carrier boards.

  • Thermal conductivity (lambda)

    Wood fibre
    About 0.036-0.043 W/mK
    Mineral wool
    About 0.035-0.044 W/mK (glass wool loft roll 0.044, stone wool slabs 0.035-0.038)
  • Density

    Wood fibre
    About 50 kg/m3 (batts) to 110-180 kg/m3 (boards)
    Mineral wool
    About 9 kg/m3 (glass wool loft roll) to 30 kg/m3 or more (stone wool batts)
  • Specific heat capacity

    Wood fibre
    About 2,100 J/kgK (declared)
    Mineral wool
    About 800-1,030 J/kgK
  • Vapour diffusion resistance (mu)

    Wood fibre
    About 2-3 (vapour open)
    Mineral wool
    About 1-2 (vapour open)
  • Moisture buffering

    Wood fibre
    Hygroscopic: takes up and releases moisture vapour
    Mineral wool
    Takes up very little moisture
  • Reaction to fire

    Wood fibre
    Typically Euroclass E
    Mineral wool
    Typically A1 or A2 (non-combustible)
  • Biogenic carbon

    Wood fibre
    Stores carbon taken up by trees
    Mineral wool
    None
  • Price

    Wood fibre
    Usually higher
    Mineral wool
    Usually lower, especially glass wool roll
  • Handling

    Wood fibre
    Wood dust when cut; no fibre itch
    Mineral wool
    Fibres can cause temporary itching; dust when cut

Typical figures from the product examples in this guide. Always use the data for the product you are buying.

Thermal performance and summer overheating

On winter heat loss, the two overlap more than people expect. A flexible wood fibre batt can declare 0.036 W/mK, and a wood fibre render board 0.037 W/mK. A stone wool slab may declare 0.035-0.038 W/mK depending on thickness, while a common glass wool loft roll declares 0.044 W/mK. Lower lambda means less thickness for the same U-value.

As a rough Matera calculation, reaching a thermal resistance (R-value) of 4.5 m2K/W takes about 160mm at 0.035-0.036 W/mK, but about 200mm at 0.044 W/mK. So compare the specific products at your target U-value, not "wood fibre" against "mineral wool".

Summer is where they differ. Wood fibre is denser than most mineral wool and declares a higher specific heat capacity, so it stores more heat and slows its passage through a roof or wall. This delay is called decrement delay or phase shift. GreenSpec gives an approximate 12-hour delay for one wood fibre roof build-up.

The Buildwise study measured heat transfer through walls, not indoor room temperature. A Buildwise (Belgium) study calculated a phase shift of about 7.4 hours for 200mm of flexible wood fibre, against about 4.3 hours for 200mm of stone wool.

In full-scale wall tests, though, swapping the insulation made a small difference: about 5% at most in the tested walls. Using a clay board inside instead of plasterboard had a bigger effect. The authors concluded that night ventilation and daytime shading should come first, and insulation type after that.

Note. Specific heat figures for biobased insulation are often generic rather than certified. The same Buildwise paper found only one certified value in a 2022 screening of data sheets, and it was lower than the usual assumption. Treat large decrement delay claims with care and ask how they were calculated.

Moisture behaviour and durability

Both materials are vapour open. Water vapour passes through them easily, so neither acts as a vapour barrier. The difference is that wood fibre is hygroscopic: it takes up moisture vapour into the fibres when the air is humid and releases it when the air is dry. Mineral wool takes up very little.

This buffering is one reason wood fibre is popular in breathable retrofit build-ups, especially with lime or clay plasters. It is not a cure-all. In the Buildwise tests, an OSB board inside the insulation did most of the buffering, and the biobased insulation behind it made little difference to indoor humidity. What finishes the room side matters as much as the insulation.

Neither material should get wet from rain, leaks, or rising damp. Wet mineral wool loses insulating performance until it dries. Wood fibre tolerates some moisture swings, but prolonged wetting can damage it. Both last for the life of the building if the build-up is designed and detailed to stay dry.

Tip. For internal insulation on solid walls, or any build-up where you are unsure about condensation, ask for a hygrothermal assessment of the whole wall rather than relying on the insulation being "breathable".

Fire performance

This is the clearest difference. Mineral wool products are typically Euroclass A1, the non-combustible class. A common stone wool slab and a common glass wool loft roll both declare A1. Wood fibre insulation is combustible and typically Euroclass E.

A combustible insulation is not automatically unsafe. Many houses use wood fibre behind plasterboard or render, and the performance of the finished build-up matters. But the class does rule wood fibre out of some uses in England.

  • Residential buildings with a storey 11m or more above ground: Approved Document B asks for insulation in external walls to be A2-s1, d0 or better, with an exception for masonry cavity walls built to its Diagram 8.2.
  • Relevant buildings with a storey 18m or more (including flats, student accommodation, and care homes): regulation 7(2) bans materials below A2-s1, d0 in external walls, with limited exemptions.
  • Any building with a storey 18m or more: insulation in external walls should be A2-s3, d2 or better under Approved Document B.
  • Lower buildings, lofts, and internal uses: wood fibre can often be used, subject to the fire strategy and the rest of the build-up.

Watch out. This is a summary of guidance for England only. Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland have their own rules. Confirm the design with your building control body or a fire engineer, and see our guide to fire performance of biobased materials.

Acoustic performance

Both are porous fibrous materials, so both absorb sound in a cavity. For blocking sound between rooms or homes, mass and the way the construction is separated matter more than the insulation itself.

Mineral wool has a practical advantage for party walls and separating floors. The example constructions in Approved Document E name mineral wool as the absorbent layer, with a minimum density of 10 kg/m3. If you use another material, you are moving away from those examples and should expect to need test evidence for the actual construction.

Wood fibre can still help. Dense wood fibre boards add mass, which helps against airborne and low-frequency noise. Ask for tested results for the full construction rather than relying on general claims.

Embodied carbon and biogenic carbon

Two different numbers get mixed up here. Fossil emissions in modules A1-A3 are the emissions from making the product. Biogenic carbon is the carbon the trees took from the air, now stored in the wood fibre. EPDs to EN 15804+A2 report the two separately, and you should keep them separate when comparing.

The two EPD examples below show why. Per square metre at the same thickness, this glass wool product has lower fossil emissions than this wood fibre batt. The wood fibre batt stores more biogenic carbon than its fossil emissions, so its A1-A3 total comes out negative.

  • Flexible wood fibre batt, 50 kg/m3 (STEICOflex)

    About 2.8 m2K/W
    Fossil emissions A1-A3
    About 3.6 kg CO2e/m2
    Biogenic carbon stored
    About 8.4 kg CO2e/m2
  • Glass wool loft roll (Knauf Loft Roll 44)

    2.25 m2K/W
    Fossil emissions A1-A3
    About 0.8 kg CO2e/m2
    Biogenic carbon stored
    None

Matera calculation from two manufacturer EPDs, scaled to 100mm. Different products and factories will give different results.

  • Stored carbon is not permanent. In the wood fibre EPD, the end-of-life scenario is incineration, which releases almost all the stored carbon again in module C3. Over the full life cycle, the biogenic carbon roughly balances out.
  • So don't read a negative A1-A3 total as "carbon negative". It describes carbon being held in the building for as long as the material stays there.
  • Stone wool is usually denser than glass wool, so its figure per square metre can be higher. Check the EPD for the exact product.
  • Transport counts. Much wood fibre sold in the UK is made in continental Europe, so ask for module A4 or the factory location.

Tip. Compare carbon per square metre at your target U-value, and keep fossil and biogenic figures in separate columns. Our embodied carbon guide explains the life cycle modules.

Cost, handling, and end of life

Mineral wool is usually the cheaper option, especially glass wool loft roll. Published UK price guides vary a lot. One 2026 cost guide puts fitted wood fibre board at roughly two to three times the price of mineral wool quilt, but it compares a rigid board with a roll, which is not like for like. Get quotes for the same U-value and the same application, including labour, membranes, and fixings.

Handling is different. Mineral wool fibres can cause temporary itching on skin, throat, or eyes, so manufacturers advise gloves and covering exposed skin. Wood fibre does not itch in the same way, but cutting it makes wood dust, which can cause asthma. Use dust extraction and suitable respiratory protection when cutting either material for any length of time.

Wood fibre batts can be cut with a handsaw or insulation knife and friction-fitted between studs. Wood fibre boards are heavier than mineral wool, which matters on scaffolds and in lofts.

TopicDetail
Wood fibre end of lifeDepending on binders and additives, it may be reused, recycled, composted, or burned for energy recovery. Check the manufacturer's guidance.
Mineral wool end of lifeIt can be recycled into new mineral wool, and factory offcuts are commonly recycled. Ask whether a take-back scheme covers your area, as site waste is often harder to recycle.
Recycled contentGlass wool can contain a large share of recycled glass. Ask for the declared percentage for the exact product, as published figures for the same product can differ.

Which to choose for each application

Use this as a starting point. The right choice depends on the whole build-up, the budget, and the rules that apply to your building.

  • Loft, between and over joists

    Wood fibre
    Works, but usually costs more
    Mineral wool
    Glass wool roll is the usual low-cost choice
    What decides it
    Budget, depth available, and eaves ventilation
  • Pitched roof at the rafters

    Wood fibre
    Strong fit, especially with wood fibre sarking boards
    Mineral wool
    Works with the right membranes
    What decides it
    Summer overheating risk and condensation design
  • Timber frame walls

    Wood fibre
    Strong fit for vapour-open walls
    Mineral wool
    Common and usually cheaper
    What decides it
    Fire strategy, airtight layer, and moisture design
  • Internal insulation on solid walls

    Wood fibre
    Often used in vapour-open systems with lime or clay plaster
    Mineral wool
    Usually in a stud frame with a vapour control layer
    What decides it
    Hygrothermal assessment, cold bridges, and tested system details
  • External wall insulation (render board)

    Wood fibre
    Works on lower buildings as part of a tested render system
    Mineral wool
    Stone wool slabs are non-combustible
    What decides it
    Building height, fire rules, and system certification
  • Party walls and separating floors

    Wood fibre
    Possible with test evidence
    Mineral wool
    Named in Approved Document E example constructions
    What decides it
    Part E compliance and sound testing
  • Strict fire requirements, such as residential external walls 11m and above

    Wood fibre
    Typical E class does not meet A2-s1, d0
    Mineral wool
    Usually the default, as A1 or A2
    What decides it
    Building control and the fire strategy

Using Matera

Ask each supplier for the declared lambda at your thickness, the density, and the BS EN 13501-1 fire classification report. For carbon, ask for a product EPD with fossil and biogenic carbon reported separately, and where the product is made.

For mineral wool, ask whether it is glass or stone wool and its recycled content. For wood fibre, ask for FSC or PEFC certification. Then compare installed prices for the same U-value, not the price per pack.

Sources

Where the facts in this guide come from. Standards and guidance change, and some sources are suppliers or trade sites, so check the original before relying on a detail.